The Profit Sector
Member Login
No Result
View All Result
The Profit Sector
Member Login
The Profit Sector
No Result
View All Result

Dogs of the Dow Explained: How a Legendary Investor Simplifies Value Investing

Adam English by Adam English
February 11, 2023
in Analysis
0
dogs of the dow image
  1. Michael B. O'Higgins and Beating The Dow
  2. The Dogs of the Dow Explained
  3. Dogs of the Dow Results
  4. Wrapping it Up and a Dividend Alternative

I have a brother who's a mathematician. And he's highly skeptical of math.

You might also like

The King of Bank Robbers: Investing in Truist (NYSE: TFC)

Flatcoins: Crypto's Answer to Inflation? Pros and Cons of the Latest Blockchain Idea

Is GameStop the Best Meme Stock? Fourth Quarter Results Are a Mic Drop

He isn't jaded. His skepticism comes from what math aims to do. He views it as a tool. What the math aims to do is as important, if not more, than the answer it gives.

In other words, finding a meaningful equation matters more than any meaning of the number you get to at the end.

Another way, again – are you even asking the right question?

A legendary investor aimed to frame the right question, and his solution has been controversial for over 30 years. Yet it remains one of the most compelling takes on value investing.

He coined the term “Dogs of the Dow.” If you're interested in finding hidden gems in plain sight, you should know about it.

Let's dig into the details and what's involved, with some examples, and take it from there.

Michael B. O'Higgins and Beating The Dow

So, who tried to ask the right question, and what meaning did he try to find?

Back in 1991, Michael B. O'Higgins published a book, Beating The Dow.

Here's a self-published biography:

In 1991, Michael B. O'Higgins, one of the nation's top money managers, turned the investment world upside down with an ingenious strategy, showing how all investors–from those with only $5,000 to invest to millionaires–could beat the pros 95% of the time by putting 100% of their equity investment into the high-yield, low-risk “dog” stocks of the Dow Jones Industrial Average. 

His formula spawned a veritable industry, including websites, mutual funds, and billions and billions of dollars worth of investments.

In the process, he established a simple mathematical equation that excluded much information others considered critical.

The answer he aimed to get and how he did it seemed too simple to many.

It removed a lot of information others considered necessary. It moved a lot slower and encouraged people to do nothing for long stretches of time.

Here is the basic version…

The Dogs of the Dow Explained

The “Dogs of the Dow” system is almost more about what is excluded than anything else.

First, ignore all other stocks except the Dow 30; there used to be some 8,000 in the mid-1990s when he wrote his book.

Then take the Dow 30 companies' dividend payments and divide them by the share price.

That calculates a simple dividend yield. Then, of those thirty companies, only invest in the ones with the highest dividend yields once per year.

The goal is to isolate companies that are undervalued compared to their peers. That's a common enough goal.

However, how much he chose to exclude in his equation was wildly contentious. Surely, people reasoned, more information was necessary.

These are already companies that get a lot of attention. Plus, they are all huge, with market capitalizations in the billions. What they do is already closely watched.

Michael B. O'Higgins said you should ignore all other factors. Once a year, divide dividend yield by share price and change your allocation.

That is it. Nothing more.

Changes to price versus earnings? Gone. Price versus book value? Same. Future revenue projections? Not an issue.

Ignore it all.

Large drops in share price that drive up relative dividend yields? It supercharges the system without any need to accommodate why.

That is the “Dogs of the Dow” system, short, simple, and wildly reductive.

Imagine going through all of 2022, where the Dow 30 lost nearly 9%, and someone told you it meant nothing at all. Ride it out. Shift some money around at the start of 2023. Touch nothing until 2024.

Only the bottom ten of the Dow 30 based on dividend yield matters once per year.

Dogs of the Dow Results

As hard as it is to accept, this once-per-year reallocation can be tracked.

Pick and choose your date, but the first of the year is pretty easy as a benchmark.

In 2022, The Dow Composite Index was down 8.79%. The S&P 500 was down 18.11%

Dow versus SP 500 2022 total return chart

Let's look at that compared to an ETF weighted for the highest-paying Dow component companies by dividend yield.

We're using the Invesco Dow Jones Industrial Average Dividend ETF (NYSEArca: DJD) as a proxy here. It is far from perfect, but it is a convenient way to prioritize the high yields of Dow companies in a one-stop-shop.

Dow versus SP 500 versus Invesco Dow Jones Industrial Average Dividend ETF (NYSEArca: DJD) total return 2022 chart

It isn't pretty, but it is a difference of over 8% compared to the total return of the Dow and over 17% compared to the total return of the S&P 500. 

The longer-term charts are clear that the strategy isn't always going to outperform.

Let's look at a chart going back to the end of 2015 to see how that looks.

Dow versus SP 500 versus Invesco Dow Jones Industrial Average Dividend ETF (NYSEArca: DJD) total return 2016 to 2022 chart

The dogs of the Dow are not as impressive here. They trail the larger indices during bullish years.

They are, after all, the ten companies with the highest yields, and a large part of that is how their share prices aren't keeping up with the rest of the pack.

Wrapping it Up and a Dividend Alternative

The Dow Dogs hold up well for such a simple system that ignores so much data. It's especially true when we're bombarded with so much market uncertainty.

Even with inflation and wild daily, weekly, or monthly market movement, the dogs of the dow show potential in a unique way.

All that data and speculation don't matter as much, with a focus on long-term trends.

It is far from the only system to do this, though.

A prime example is dividend aristocrat stocks. They are stocks that have grown dividend payments annually for at least 25 years.

Here's one last chart dating back to February 2022, when the Federal Reserve first started increasing interest rates at an aggressive pace.

This chart adds the ProShares S&P 500 Dividend Aristocrats ETF (BATS: NOBL) to show that we can use other long-term tools that capitalize on long-term trends.

Dow versus SP 500 versus Invesco Dow Jones Industrial Average Dividend ETF (NYSEArca: DJD) versus ProShares S&P 500 Dividend Aristocrats ETF (BATS: NOBL) total return Feb 2022 year to date chart

They may be more complex, slightly, but a long-term outlook can be defined in many ways. We need not stick to one.

The dogs of the Dow are a very interesting way of looking at the market, nonetheless. Here's hoping it helps show how purposely removing a lot of information – often pointless, anxiety-inducing noise – can reveal a valid, if contentious, market strategy.

Take care,

adam english profit sector signature

Adam English
The Profit Sector

Related Posts

  • 2023's Top 10 Dogs of the Dow
  • Legendary Investor: “More Losses to Come”
  • The Investor's Guide to Investing in a Bear Market or Recession
Tags: Beating the Dow bookdividend investingDogs of the DowInvesco Dow Jones Industrial Average Dividend ETF (NYSEArca: DJD)Michael B O'Higgins
Adam English

Adam English

My background in history led to an interest in financial and market research, which led to positions at several of the leading financial newsletter companies in the U.S.A. For over a decade, I've worked alongside ex-brokers, options floor traders, financial advisors, and some of the most experienced editors in the field. Starting at the ground floor in financial publishing – including customer service – and working my way up, I'm acutely aware of the challenges faced by retail investors. Challenges that have only multiplied since the Great Recession and COVID pandemic have exacerbated market distortion and investor uncertainty.

Recommended For You

The King of Bank Robbers: Investing in Truist (NYSE: TFC)

by Jimmy Mengel
March 30, 2023
0
The King of Bank Robbers: Investing in Truist (NYSE: TFC)

The banking crisis had provided investors with a "blood in the streets" moment. Here's one bank stock for big dividends and big returns...

Read more

Flatcoins: Crypto’s Answer to Inflation? Pros and Cons of the Latest Blockchain Idea

by Adam English
March 29, 2023
0

Flatcoins might be a fantastic new development for cryptocurrencies. Can they escape the pitfalls of the past? Let's look at what's new, what they offer, and what risks...

Read more

Is GameStop the Best Meme Stock? Fourth Quarter Results Are a Mic Drop

by Adam English
March 24, 2023
0
Is GameStop the Best Meme Stock? Fourth Quarter Results Are a Mic Drop

GameStop Corp (NASDAQ: GME) just didn't something it hasn't in years. It made some money. What does it mean for a meme stock? Let's dig back and look...

Read more

Gold Investments and Bank Runs: What A Classic Alternative Investment Offers Today

by Adam English
March 23, 2023
0
Gold Investments and Bank Runs: What A Classic Alternative Investment Offers Today

Alternative investments are seeing a boost, none more than gold. Here's how it's panning out...

Read more

An Arsonist’s Guide to the Banking Crisis

by Jimmy Mengel
March 22, 2023
0
An Arsonist’s Guide to the Banking Crisis

The Fed is acting as firefighter and arsonist at the same time. That's what led to the most recent bank collapse...

Read more
Next Post
money bomb risk

2023 Debt Ceiling Explained: What It Means For Investors

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

The King of Bank Robbers: Investing in Truist (NYSE: TFC)

The King of Bank Robbers: Investing in Truist (NYSE: TFC)

March 30, 2023

Flatcoins: Crypto’s Answer to Inflation? Pros and Cons of the Latest Blockchain Idea

March 29, 2023
Jeff Clark Trader’s The One-Trade Retirement Blueprint

Jeff Clark Trader Review: One-Trade Retirement Blueprint

March 29, 2023
Are We Headed Towards a Train Wreck?

Are We Headed Towards a Train Wreck?

March 25, 2023
  • Home
  • Member Login
  • What is The Profit Sector?
  • Meet Our Team
  • Join The Profit Sector Monthly
  • FAQs
  • Featured Articles
  • Dividends and Income
  • Analysis
  • Investment Strategies
  • Saturday Digest
  • Newsletter Reviews
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy for The Profit Sector
Contact Us

Protected by copyright laws of the United States and international treaties. This website may only be used pursuant to the Terms and Conditions and any reproduction, copying, or redistribution (electronic or otherwise, including on the World Wide Web), in whole or in part, is strictly prohibited without the express written permission of The Profit Sector, LLC. 415 1st Ave N #19868, Seattle, WA 98109

© 2022 The Profit Sector, LLC. All rights reserved. Our website provides stock market research, commentary, and analysis. Information is provided “as is” and solely for information purposes, not for trading purposes or advice.

Nothing on this website should be considered personalized financial advice. Any investments recommended herein should be made only after consulting with your personal investment advisor and only after performing your own research and due diligence, including reviewing the prospectus or financial statements of the issuer of any security. The Profit Sector, its managers, its employees, affiliates and assigns (collectively "The Company") do not make any guarantee or warranty about the advice provided on this website or what is otherwise advertised above. The Company is not registered or licensed by any governing body in any jurisdiction to give investing advice or provide investment recommendation. The Company is not affiliated with, nor does it receive compensation from, any specific security. To the maximum extent permitted by law, the Company disclaims any and all liability in the event any information, commentary, analysis, opinions, advice and/or recommendations provided herein prove to be inaccurate, incomplete or unreliable, or result in any investment or other losses.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Member Login
  • What is The Profit Sector?
  • Meet Our Team
  • Saturday Digest
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Privacy Policy for The Profit Sector
  • Terms and Conditions

Protected by copyright laws of the United States and international treaties. This website may only be used pursuant to the Terms and Conditions and any reproduction, copying, or redistribution (electronic or otherwise, including on the World Wide Web), in whole or in part, is strictly prohibited without the express written permission of The Profit Sector, LLC. 415 1st Ave N #19868, Seattle, WA 98109

© 2022 The Profit Sector, LLC. All rights reserved. Our website provides stock market research, commentary, and analysis. Information is provided “as is” and solely for information purposes, not for trading purposes or advice.

Nothing on this website should be considered personalized financial advice. Any investments recommended herein should be made only after consulting with your personal investment advisor and only after performing your own research and due diligence, including reviewing the prospectus or financial statements of the issuer of any security. The Profit Sector, its managers, its employees, affiliates and assigns (collectively "The Company") do not make any guarantee or warranty about the advice provided on this website or what is otherwise advertised above. The Company is not registered or licensed by any governing body in any jurisdiction to give investing advice or provide investment recommendation. The Company is not affiliated with, nor does it receive compensation from, any specific security. To the maximum extent permitted by law, the Company disclaims any and all liability in the event any information, commentary, analysis, opinions, advice and/or recommendations provided herein prove to be inaccurate, incomplete or unreliable, or result in any investment or other losses.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist